Monday, 17 December 2012

But i'm with Banco Espanol not business banking


To use a catch phrase from  the olden days (as my kids would call it) “I wanna tell you a story”.

Last week I went to my bank’s premises (a former  building society) to pay in a business cheque. I have both my personal account and business account with this institution for simplicity and convenience Hmmm, or so I thought.

I handed over a cheque which I wanted paid into my business bank. “I’m sorry but you will have to pay that in through the ATM machine” was the rather frosty edict from the cashier.

“But I’ve done it over the counter before” I protested.

“ That is only the case when the ATM option is not available” was the next rebuff. 

Quickly followed up by “ We don’t do business banking here in the branch”

As far as I’m concerned there is no difference between Banco Espanol and business banking they are all the same brand irrespective of whether one is for personal banking and the other for business customers.

So what can Banco Espanol learn from this experience. Don’t put up artificial silos because from a customer perspective you are all one Bank irrespective of internal structures. Put yourself in the customers shoes.

Secondly perhaps the cashier could have employed some flexibility and not been such a “job’s worth” The refusal of the cashier to process my cheque meant it took 5 business days to clear.

Keeping up the Iberian theme, what could I have done about the can’t/won’t do mentality I experienced – perhaps grow some large cojones !!

Muchas gracias for reading my pequeno blog,

Linkedin endorsements finger clicking bad


Aren’t I the big star with over 1500 linked connections and numerous endorsements.

Well actually the thing I court the most within Linkedin is the recommendation from a connection. To be able to write a meaningful recommendation that connection has to know me well and either have experienced my work first hand or seen it as an observer.

So when I get endorsements from connections that have never seen me doing my training stuff it means nothing to me. I really only want recommendations because people will have thought about what they write rather than just clicking endorse.

So whilst I may show an abundance of endorsements to anyone checking out my profile, it don’t cut the mustard with me. Call me old fashioned but it doesn’t seem right to be endorsed by people who don’t know me that well and who haven’t been Dell’Armied ! It devalues the endorsements and it’s the lazy person’s way – a bit like a Facebook like.

There maybe some algorithm type thingy going on here with search ranking (which I don’t pretend to understand) which may benefit me but from an authenticity perspective it just doesn’t sit comfortably with me.

Would love to hear what others think.

Friday, 7 December 2012

Would we in learning & development last 5 minutes if we worked for Roman Abramovich ?


As Roberto Di Matteo and many football managers know you are only as good as your last game which for Di Matteo was a 3-0 defeat to Juve. If ever there was a profession that personified the phrase “ it’s a results business” it has to be the fickle yet beautiful game.

This got me thinking ? What if Mr Abramovich decided to employ me as a freelancer or he decided to buy a training company. Would we be able to say well, Sir you spent £x amount on training and this is how it affected the profits of your business.

Maybe this lack of demonstrable value add/ROI is the reason why the first thing to be cut back in times of recession is training.

But equally not investing in training can be devastating to a business as Toyota learnt ,when  the problems that resulted in product recalls in 2011 were down to the fact that proper training hadn’t been carried out.

It strikes me that in times of austerity the only training that gets done is the mandatory stuff.

Why is that ? It comes back to lack of demonstrable value add. Training without application and transfer of learning is entertrainment and we’re not in the entertrainment business. So as professionals we need to be more than simply order takers .

So if we are asked to run a training event we should consider asking some of the following questions:

  • What is the issue that the event is trying to solve ?
  • How does that issue manifest itself ?
  • How much is it costing you currently ?
  • How much extra income would you expect to be generated as a result of the training
  • What needs to happen (post event) to make sure that the training or new skills learnt on the day are successfully transferred back into the workplace
  • How will we know that the training has made a difference ? (measures of success)

So as a profession we need to ask the right questions of our customers in order to be able to show that we’ve made a difference and be able to quantify that difference, then training wont be the first thing to be chopped in difficult times.

Until we start doing this, training will just be seen as a cost by the bean counters.


Monday, 3 December 2012

Sorry George but we don't owe you a bean !


“For more than three decades, Starbucks had a storied history of being a great place to work, of ethically sourcing and roasting the highest quality coffee beans” The above quote comes from the inside cover of  “Onward” by Howard Schultz (Starbucks CEO) . Ethical sourcing and roasting undoubtedly but clearly not ethical enough to pay a single bean of UK Corporation Tax. 

Thanks to the way the business is structured and expenses apportioned (I don’t pretend to understand the mechanics of their accounting and tax avoidance) they have not paid one single penny in UK Corporation Tax. They allege that they made a loss in the UK.

Don’t get me wrong; what Starbucks have done is not illegal ! BUT it is clearly immoral. Add this corporate behaviour to the following examples of how to destroy trust:

·         Banks who rigged the libor rate
·         MPs who fiddled their expenses
·         News of the World journalists who hacked into mobile phones unlawfully.

Organisations exist in society and from a corporate social responsibility point of view should look to give something back which generally Starbucks has been pretty good at. But organisations if they want our trust and custom need to behave ethically and what Starbucks has done falls well short of the standards of acceptable behaviour.

I suggest, that if we as consumers demonstrate our abhorrence to this type of behaviour by taking our patronage elsewhere this will focus the minds of brands on how they should conduct their affairs.

 I could go on roasting Starbucks ….. . This morning I had a business meeting and whilst my tipple was the usual latte the venue wasn’t. You’re going to have to show a lot of contrition and a new behaviour to win my custom back and not become a has bean!

PS I’m not ignoring Google or Amazon who appear to have underpaid UK Corporation Tax allegedly

Wednesday, 14 November 2012

To communicate to your employees or not, that is the question



How much time should you spend talking and communicating to your people. At a CIPD event I attended the HR director of John Lewis said they spend 60% of their time doing exactly this.

Seems rather a lot – well here’s why you need to keep your people in the loop from a friend's true story

He recounts, how he  was waiting to checkin at Alicante Airport at 5.30 in the morning within a large queue.  No one likes queuing at the best of times but at stupid o’clock tempers can become frayed and patience is severely tested.

“ Probably with my frustration mounting I heard a passenger in front of me (whose Uncle works at my home airport) regaling to several passengers that landing fees were so expensive at my local airport and that the Spanish Airline Vueling would be pulling out. Needless to say I corrected her on several issues.”

My friend continued “ However it does rather beg the question how often are staff (at my local airport) briefed on improvements being made, the new routes coming on-stream and the negative impact of old myths like landing fees, if stories like this are still being  perpetuated”

Employees should be your biggest supporters and ambassadors for your brand and business. Communication is a key driver of employee engagement and successful change.

Still think communication is a waste of time ?

Wednesday, 8 August 2012

The financial services industry needs to step up to the plate & fulfil its destiny


In an article the Western Mail the CEO of the Monmouthshire Building Society states that creating a better financial services sector in the UK will not be the result of “bank bashing”.

 As someone who considers  themselves something of a financial services veteran (defined as 25 plus years experience),  this got me thinking.

Clearly Financial services has been tainted by behaviour of the banks & the insurers who mis-sold Personal Pensions & mortgage related Endowment policies. Clearly the industry has an image problem & is not trusted by the people who should be its biggest advocates – its customers !

This inherent mistrust of the industry and in some cases the inbuilt complexity, jargon and lack of transparency continue to confuse and confound the problem of lack of protection & security in key areas for consumers. In other words, consumers lack the very basic products that could make a real difference to their financial wellbeing.

So here is a ten point pledge that all providers of financial products should sign up to:

  • Treat customers as they would expect to be treated themselves
  • Design and manufacture products and services that are easy to understand
  • Make essential products affordable and accessible to all
  • Write customer communication that customers can understand
  • Look after your customers first and  shareholders second
  • Create customer experiences that are memorable for the right reasons
  • Remember that every enquiry, letter, telephone call, case, claim, policy number is a real person. Focus on the person not the task
  • Remember whose money it is that you are collecting and managing
  • Offer additional discounts for existing customers on new products
  • Scrap all sales targets and get your salesforce to focus on serving the customer first and foremost. Build relationships with customer and play the long game to rebuild trust. 

Do all of the above and financial services can grow up and fulfil its destiny & become the force for good that it should be !




Thursday, 2 August 2012

Succession planning at the Principality- that's the way to do it


The big news in the Cardiff business community is that Graeme Yorston is to succeed Peter Griffiths as the CEO of the Principality Building Society #.  Griffiths, led the society for ten years (of which the last four have been incredibly difficult for the industry) and in a style and way that has enabled the Mutual to avoid the problems and bad publicity affecting other financial institutions.

This news, got me thinking . So how do you replace such a capable leader ? What is the process ? Was Yorston the only person to be considered ? Had the resignation of Griffiths forced the board to think of a successor ? Or had the board been proactively thinking about, when this day arrived, who would be stepping into Griffith’s shoes ?  Essentially what these questions are attempting to discover is whether there was a succession plan.

So if you were being proactive and planning for the CEO’s departure how would you go about putting in place such a plan and what would be involved ? Four years ago I wrote my CIPD Management Research Report,  “Future Proofing The Organisation” on  how do you succession plan?

Essentially the steps to follow are:

Create a written succession plan – with the primary goal being the development of internal successors. Additionally emergency succession procedures should be included, to cover  situations such as sudden death or long term sickness of the CEO.

Develop a required set of capabilities -  compare the resulting list against the firm’s senior talent pipeline. Ensure that the board has regular exposure to internal candidates through presentations, field observations and site visits.

Conduct regular in depth reviews – the entire board with the senior HR executive should review the plan twice a year to make sure that it continues to be fit for purpose in the light of the ever evolving business environment and company strategy.

Narrow the field down to two or three contenders – this should occur about two years before transition.

Implement the plan, about a year before the anticipated departure through:

  • Indepth competency focused interviews
  • 360 degree feedback
  • Psychometric Testing

Then finally the board should make it’s decision

And that’s all there is to it ? Did the Principality follow this methodology, my guess is probably yes. Good luck to Yorston in his new role.

# The Principality is 7th Largest Building society in the UK and in the past 6 months attracted £160M and 28,000 new customers in the first 6 months of this year.